HIRING VS CONTRACTING YOUR PRACTICE-REP

What about recruiting?

In this second of a series looking at facets of the question many medical specialists are forced to ponder in an increasingly competitive field we consider the task of recruiting the best representative to market your practice.

You may be aware of data1 supporting the increased value of referral marketing, or perhaps you’re simply following the lead of progressive hospitals as they garner increasing shares of patients within your catchment area. What many don’t realize, however, are the difficulties associated with recruiting high caliber sales people to fit the bill for the marketing of medical specialties. They’re essentially specialists in their own right; hybrids, if you will.

In a recent job board ad a prominent university hospital was recruiting a professional for the “newly created position” of Manager of Physician Liaison. That person will “be responsible for growth by earning referrals from physicians to [the] nationally recognized hospital.” This demonstrates what more hospitals are doing to drive patients to their growing corals of specialists and service providers. Job requirements for the position, which, incidentally, are far surpassed by those within Practice-Reps, include abilities in both the business and medical fields.

In the past many physicians have futilely asked clinicians to pursue sales agenda without the integral training and guidance. It’s been like jamming square pegs into round holes. The fact is there aren’t many people out there with experience in the marketing of medical practices. They need experience in sales, services and practice management. Those people are hard to find.

At Practice-Reps we understand the intricacies of working in the worlds of both business and medicine. We take our decades of knowledge and experience in sales, medical sales and practice management consulting and combine them to form a marketing team for each of our practices. We actually create your representative by constructing a position tailored to market your practice.

Although clinical people are familiar with hospitals, treating patients and so on, we recruit people with experience in sales, and more specifically, medical sales. And while we look for experience in practice management as well, we reinforce what skills they have in that area by teaching them the nuances of marketing and selling the capabilities of a medical practice. Additionally, the physician that hires a clinician to market his practice normally lacks experience in managing remote sales personnel.

Of those trying to hire their own reps many have made the assumption that pharmaceutical reps are qualified to be practice reps. But that business model is not a good fit for this reason: a pharma rep is trained to be process oriented. They go into a doctor’s office, drop off samples and get signatures. They may talk about an issue using coached buzz-words and then they leave. They’re process oriented.

On the other hand, the supply or device rep or certain other medical sales people are more results oriented. They have to gain an advance towards the end result: making a sale. We do hire some pharma reps that have business to business experience, but the pharma model really doesn’t work well for marketing medical specialty practices.

Despite that, we still see clients go alone and hire a friend, often a pharma rep. They’re not going to be able to manage that person because they can’t be objective with a friend. And their return on investment suffers by hiring an employee who’s not results oriented. They’re not going to see the same results they will with Practice-Reps.

By working with experts like our teams at Practice-Reps you enlist professionals. We know how to recruit, who to recruit, how to motivate, and how to entice them. We coach them in all aspects of marketing your practice. We collectively have over 50 years of experience in the industry. We’ve hired, trained and managed over 600 professional medical sales people for previous carriers. From experience we know what job boards work for recruiting the best reps. More importantly, we are constantly networking with the entire medical sales and marketing community, reaching out and building a reputation that enables us to recruit just the right person on almost a moment’s notice. We’re able to communicate with that unique individual in ways that will challenge and engage.

Your rep is not just someone filling a hole. The effectiveness of that person will have a direct impact on your bottom line. Your edge in competing against the hospitals and larger groups in your catchment area may hinge on this recruitment process. At Practice-Reps we’ve proven the value of hiring the right people – the first time.

Call us today at 610-323-4793. We’ll be happy to discuss your needs and how referral marketing can help your bottom line.

PLEASE BE SURE TO CHECK CASE STUDIES FROM ACTUAL EXPERIENCE WITH OUR CLIENTS, PROVING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF OUR BUSINESS MODEL.


1 Referral Programs and Customer Value – page 25 – Philipp Schmitt, Bernd Skiera and Christophe Van den Bulte, July 25, 2010

Medical referral marketing in USA Today, Wall Street Journal

If you thought referral marketing was a crazy fad think again.  Below are two recent articles in the national press, USA Today, and Smart Money Magazine from the Wall Street Journal, which discuss this emerging trend in healthcare management.

We joke about this being an emerging trend because certain markets have been doing this for decades while the East Coast seems to be just catching on in 2012.  Many would assume that a trend like this began in the competitive environs of California but we seem to link this trend back to Indiana where virtually every practice engages in some type of medical practice marketing.  The December 2011 article in USA Today points out practices in the Chicago suburbs who actively promote their capabilities with a Practice-Rep or Physician Liaison.

The difference between the two titles is this; Physician Liaison’s typically are employed by a hospital where they market service lines such as cardiology, surgery, etc.  Practice-Reps tend to be employed by privately owned specialty practices where they market the capabilities of just that practice and no others in that community.  With a Liaison, you’re lumped into a service line.  With a Practice-Rep you are front and center stage to the referral community.

Below is a help wanted ad from a leading teaching hospital here in Philadelphia.  They are advertising for a “newly created position” of Manager of Physician Liaison’s.  Take a look at the job description and you’ll see that they are serious about going after referrals in their catchment communities.  Fortunately our credentials exceed their job requirements for this position so you can rest assured that “Your management team” will exceed the requirements of this premier institution.

Job Description We currently have a strategically key, newly created position available to be responsible for growth by earning referrals from physicians to our nationally recognized hospital. The Manager will be responsible for creating referral development plans based on __________ University Hospital’s strategic and operating plans, physician liaison business plan and market intelligence. The manager will have oversight for the field team, responsible for hiring and maintaining a team that professionally represents the organization and accomplishes the assigned tasks. This person will understand the practice of medicine including referral relationships, payor requirements and other economic and financial influences. This position is eligible for up to 20% of base pay in incentive bonus compensation.

Job Requirements Qualifications Minimum Bachelor degree required, preferably in business, healthcare administration, or public health administration. Previous leadership or management experience preferred. Hospital experience required. Previous experience as physician liaison preferred. Minimum of five (5) to seven (7) years of sales experience, preferably with physicians and/or health care provider setting. Ability to write and implement a marketing/sales plan. Ability to plan, organize and manage resources within prescribed timeframes (prioritize and focus). Ability to present, probe, persuade and actively listen to referral source needs and respond with the right mix of service line and product attributes that produces results. Ability and willingness to learn new software as needed to ensure efficiency and effectiveness. Strong direct relationship sales skills preferred. Ability to work within a team structure, integrating and collaborating with various leadership and management groups to strategize and drive results. Conceptual and critical thinking skills required. Strong quantitative and analytical skills required.

The link below takes you to the April 17th article in Smart Money magazine from The Wall Street Journal http://www.smartmoney.com/plan/health-care/the-surprising-secret-behind-doctor-referrals-1334332558571/
Below is the December, 2011 article from USA Today which further details this concept of direct field reps and referral marketing.

Hospitals hire reps to sell doctors on patient referrals

By Phil Galewitz, Kaiser Health News

In northwest Indiana, Carrie Sota visits five or six doctors’ offices every workday as part of her new sales job.

By John Zich, USA TODAY

Carrie Sota, physician liaison at University of Chicago Medical Center, talks with coworker Anthony Turner.

But Sota isn’t selling the physicians on a prescription drug or a medical device. She’s promoting her hospital — the University of Chicago Medical Center.

Sota, 30, is one of four employees the academic medical center has hired in recent months to make “sales calls” on physicians in the hope that they will send more patients to the hospital. “We are trying to build meaningful relationships,” said Sota, who was previously a saleswoman for a small medical device company.

The University of Chicago Medical Center is one of a growing number of hospitals nationwide hiring former drug and device sales reps to visit doctors’ offices to persuade them to use their services over competing facilities.

Rather than handing out samples of prescription drugs, the sales reps call on doctors armed with the latest information on how their facility is reducing hospital-acquired infections and improving patient-satisfaction scores.

In visits that can last five to 20 minutes, reps try to win doctors’ loyalty by helping them get better times on operating room schedules or easier patient referrals to hospital-based specialists. The sales reps can also carry messages back to the hospital, such as a doctor’s request for a new medical device to be available in surgery.

While hospitals have always tried to woo doctors to refer patients to them, the institutions are growing more direct in their efforts. The hospitals mine data to see which doctors have the most profitable, well-insured patients, and then they assign those doctors to a sales rep.

‘Physician liaisons’ on the rise

Convinced the sales-call strategy is fueling higher admissions, Tenet Healthcare, the nation’s third-largest for-profit hospital chain, has doubled its sales force in the past two years. It now has 152 “physician liaisons” at its 49 hospitals, most of which are in California, Texas and Florida.

About two-thirds of Tenet’s liaisons are former drug and device sales reps, and they can make tens of thousands of dollars in bonuses if doctors increase their referrals to the hospitals. “These people are really good and really assertive and very sophisticated,” said Stephen Newman, Tenet’s chief operating officer.

But they do have critics.

Paul Ginsburg, president of the non-partisan Center for Studying Health System Change, said, “When you look at the health system, this is a waste of resources. It’s a zero-sum game.”

He added: “The net results of changing physician-referral patterns is that one hospital gains at a cost of others, and all the hospitals burn resources to pay (sales)people who take up the doctor’s time.”

While federal law prohibits hospitals from paying doctors to admit patients, hospitals paying salespeople to influence doctors can get the same results, he said.

Newman said Tenet’s liaisons have strict guidelines so they can’t “game the system” to reach financial bonuses. For example, their bonuses can’t be tied to just one doctor’s referrals.

As a result of major cutbacks by pharmaceutical and medical-device companies in the past decade, hospitals have thousands of former medical salespeople to draw from. Tenet’s roster of sales associates includes alumni of pharmaceutical and device giants Sanofi-Aventis, GlaxoSmithKline, Johnson & Johnson and Novartis.

Newman said the company is focused on increasing referrals from doctors who split their patient referrals among multiple hospitals, as well as from physicians who don’t yet refer to Tenet facilities. Since 2007, the company credits its physician liaisons with helping to boost the numbers of doctors who actively refer patients to its hospitals by 39%, or more than 4,500 doctors.

Hospitals say their new sales approach is part of a broader strategy to develop closer ties to physicians, who largely determine where patients go for care. Hospitals also are buying doctors’ practices or forming closer partnerships with physicians to improve care and drive admissions.

“I think everyone wants to grow their market, and lots of hospitals see that the No. 1 way to get referrals is physician-to-physician interaction, and the second-best way is physician-to-physician-liaison interaction,” said Christine Perry, who manages the physician liaison program at Duke University Health System. Unlike most hospitals that have hired marketing people for the positions, Duke hires nurses as its liaisons.

Specialists are profitable

Many of the physician liaisons focus on specialists, who bring in patients for services with the highest profit margins, including orthopedics, cardiac care and cancer care, Perry said. But the sales calls also extend to internists and family doctors.

In fact, she said, a big factor behind the trend is that many primary care physicians no longer visit their patients in the hospital, because most hospitals have full-time physicians called hospitalists who care for patients in the facility. As a result, hospitals have fewer opportunities to interact with doctors in the community to tell them about a new CT scanner or new specialist.

Dr. Kaveh Safavi, the lead health industry consultant for Accenture, said hospitals are seeking ways to keep beds filled in the face of efforts by government and private insurers to reduce hospitalizations by eliminating pay for unnecessary admissions. “Hospitals know they have to create a larger funnel for a bigger population of patients to make their way to them,” he said.

Kathy DeVries, vice president of marketing at University of Chicago Medical Center, said the former drug sales reps understand how to work with doctors. “They speak their language,” she said. The hospital is now trying to hire a sales rep focused solely on pediatricians. In its help-wanted ad, the hospital said the liaison will have a goal of making 160 contacts a month with physician offices, including “25 meaningful face-to-face contacts with physicians.”

One downside to hiring former drug and device sales reps is that their medical knowledge usually focuses on a single specialty, such as diabetes treatment or orthopedics. In pitching their hospital to a doctor, the sales reps have to be familiar with a wider range of hospital services, Perry said.

Keeping doctors informed

HCA, the nation’s largest for-profit hospital chain, has at least 150 employees who make physician visits — or about one per hospital, said spokesman Ed Fishbough. He said about 90% of them visit doctors who already send some of their patients to HCA hospitals. “It’s to give our physicians and their patients a voice and to listen to any concerns the doctors may have and to address those,” he said.

Michelle Osipowicz, who spent five years as a sales representative for at Takeda Pharmaceuticals, is enjoying that aspect of her new role as a liaison for The Hospital of Central Connecticut.

“I act as a conduit between the hospital and the doctors in the community,” said Osipowicz, who visits up to eight offices a day, sometimes dropping in unannounced to chat with office staff about the hospital’s services or its latest medical specialists. “I bring more value to the physician office. I feel more respected in this role,” she said.

Kaiser Health News is an editorially independent program of the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation, a non-profit, non-partisan health policy research and communication organization not affiliated with Kaiser Permanente.

END OF ARTICLE

Referral marketing is not new and done right, it can be highly effective for physicians and patients alike.  The reality is that hospitals and progressive practices are embracing this approach to secure and grow their referrals and it’s time that you and your associates give this serious consideration.

We’ve been helping practices grow their referrals for more than 20 years.  We’re East Coast based and we have the credentials, experience, and references to help you make an informed decision.  Call us today at 610-323-4793.  www.practice-reps.com

To drive patients and referrals to your medical practice is it better to hire your own employee or to contract with a professional marketing firm?

While this may sound like a two sided question, both the theoretical and empirical evidence support the latter.  In these articles we’ll examine the reasons, all of which have been proven by actual case studies involving past experience with our clients. And while considering all facets of the question, they generally fall into one of the following areas:

  • COSTS
  • RECRUITING
  • TRAINING
  • REPORTING
  • MONITORING
  • MOTIVATING
  • SCHEDULING

COSTS

Everyone in business knows it all comes down to the bottom line. While advertising may help the average family practice, it’s a poor return on investment for the average medical specialist. To cut through the gate keepers and clutter and influence the actual decision makers in a referral source requires the human element afforded by direct marketing.

Selling your practice to other providers is not rocket science, but it does require a high caliber professional experienced in the marketing of medical specialties. And they don’t come cheap. For example, the annual income for a good pharmaceutical rep is about a hundred thousand dollars. Quality employees ultimately demand higher salaries. And to bring someone of this caliber on board usually means hiring a full time employee. We’ve found a way around this hurdle.

The average specialty practice has a catchment area of about a hundred and twenty practices within their reasonable geography. For our clients we target those providers, seeing about eight per day. At that rate all potential referral sources are quickly seen. If you’re doing this full time for a single practice, your targets are seen much too often, (Within 15 days). While marketing your practice to providers in the field needs to be done on a consistent basis, seeing them too often is not justified in the end and may in fact cause more harm than good.

Through our tailored recruitment techniques and experienced coaching we send a high-caliber part-time employee into the field to market your practice exclusively. They see about eight to ten practices in the one day per week representing you. That same employee will then market another specialty in an adjoining or non-competing area. For example, if you’re a cardiologist, our rep markets your practice part-time, and may then market a gastroenterologist in an adjoining county. We’ll spread out that employee to serve two or three practices, each on a part-time basis, until they’re working at or near full time. That way you get the representation you need by high caliber personnel managed by an experienced marketing firm. You don’t break your budget and you don’t stress over remote employees. The employee gets the salary they need, they don’t lose momentum, and they don’t get bored.

An added advantage to contracting is what you don’t take on by hiring another employee, such as advertising, interviewing, taxes, insurance, tracking, and so on. We manage all that for you. We closely monitor, challenge, and motivate your representative. And dismissing an ineffective employee can involve its own headaches. Contracting with a field marketing firm like Practice-Reps gives you turn-key marketing which you can cancel at any time.

We’re confident, however, that after you examine your options to directly market your practice you’ll find ours is the business model that works. We’re professional, experienced, and proven with a track record of success!

Give us a call today at 610-323-4793.

PLEASE BE SURE TO CHECK CASE STUDIES FROM ACTUAL EXPERIENCE WITH OUR CLIENTS, PROVING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF OUR BUSINESS MODEL.

MGMA data analysis guides the way

The MGMA Connexion magazine is perhaps my favorite journal and I always turn first to the “datamine” column by David Gans, VP of MGMA-ACMPE Inn ovation and Research.  David always provides interesting insight into the “numbers” of a medical practice and shows us how to use these as guideposts [...] Continue Reading…

Contract business development continues to drive Practice-Reps revenue

Over the years we have been contacted by numerous entities who are interested in contracting for limited business development projects.  We are happy to consider these projects and we have been quite successful with most.

These entities have included; on site vascular labs, medical billing, mobile ultrasound, PET centers, wound [...] Continue Reading…

How do we get into see decision makers in the referral process?

I met with a prospective client in a GI/endoscopy practice last week who asked how we get into see busy decision makers.  I wish I had one pat answer in return.  All I can say is that we are trained to do this.

The whole foundation of our firm is [...] Continue Reading…

Ancillary services study by MGMA

Cost Crunch of ancillary services

MGMA e-source released an interesting analysis of The MGMA Cost Survey for Single Specialty Practices:  2011 Report Based on 2010 Data entitled “Cost Crunch: Ancillary services can soften the impact of declining revenue and profits in some cases but not all”. This study serves as [...] Continue Reading…

Do Hospitals really market your practice?

I’ve been hearing from a lot of practices these days who tell me “The hospital markets our practice”. When I ask “what does that mean?” nobody ever seems to have an answer. It’s as though practices are being lulled into compliance by the alliance with some local institution [...] Continue Reading…

We already visit our referral sources

Sometimes I hear this from prospective clients who feel they don’t need our services because they already meet with their referral sources.  To them I say “great”!  They clearly recognize the need to create personal relationships between their professional peers for the good of their practice.

When I dig deeper [...] Continue Reading…

Practice-Reps Case Study: Market Intelligence

As you plan to market your practice to the referring community market intelligence can be key to an effective plan, one that saves you considerable dollars while you focus your efforts in the appropriate areas at just the right time. This intelligence can most easily be gained by having [...] Continue Reading…